Sugary drink tax could use some work

The weekly editorial for the 100 Mile Free Press

As part of the 2020 budget, the B.C. government announced that they would be adding PST to carbonated sugary drinks. The seven per cent tax will also be extended to all beverages dispensed through soda fountains, soda guns or similar equipment, as well as all beverages in vending machines, with the exception of those dedicated to serving drinks other than sweet drinks such as coffee or water. However, according to the budget, the latter is for administrative ease.

There are two ways to take that; you can see it as a cash grab or you can see it as an attempt to reduce consumption of (primarily) carbonated beverages. How you take it doesn’t really matter as it likely will do both regardless.

The more interesting question, undoubtedly, is what are the loopholes and/or potential consequences? Assuming the tax has the intended effect (something that’s not a guarantee), people will buy far fewer carbonated drinks. In terms of exemptions first and most clearly, non-carbonated sugary drinks will be exempt in a number of situations (i.e. a grocery store). In 100 Mile House, when Safeway was still here, it was notoriously popular for lunch with students. Switching from something like cola to ice tea doesn’t seem like much of a health win. However, and perhaps more harmfully, energy drinks also aren’t always carbonated (i.e. Monster Rehab, Rockstar Recovery Orange etc.). Furthermore, unlike pop, energy drinks have been increasing in popularity as opposed to pop which has already decreased in popularity.

I don’t know about other parents, but while I’m not keen on my kids drinking pop, I’d certainly prefer it over them drinking energy drinks. While my kids are still too young to make these kinds of choices for themselves, the government, in an admittedly roundabout way, incentivizing some energy drinks over pop is a real head-scratcher.

Furthermore, for those enjoying something to drink with their meal in a restaurant, perhaps one of the least sugary alternatives to cola and similar drinks, other than water, is soda water. However, with the tax applying to everything on soda guns and fountains that option is also disincentivized.

Finally, for a government that claims to be ecoconscious, this policy is also a bit of a head-scratcher. By applying the policy to everything on guns and fountains, it applies to non-carbonated beverages on the fountain such as ice-tea and lemonade. This, in turn, may incentivize buyers to buy bottled ice-tea, lemonade and other bottled products instead, increasing the number of empty bottles that need to be recycled or end up in a landfill.

Perhaps the intent behind the policy was good but you have to wonder if the execution couldn’t have been a bit more well-rounded.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

UPDATED: Interior Health to add 495 long-term seniors care beds

Nelson, Kelowna, Kamloops, Vernon and Penticton to receive new facilities

Graffiti sprayed on 100 Mile Community Hall

‘We’re having a hard time through this COVID’

Have you been following the Justin Trudeau and WE Charity story?

The weekly web poll for the 100 Mile Free Press

Highway 97 to be repaved in 100 Mile House following complaints

‘It’s been over a month now since those holes have been developing’

South Cariboo piano students see success at online exams

‘I like learning new songs and then actually getting to play them well’

Recent surge in COVID-19 cases not unexpected amid Phase Three of reopening: B.C.’s top doc

Keep circles small, wear masks and be aware of symptoms, Dr. Bonnie Henry says

B.C. NDP changing WorkSafeBC regulations to respond to COVID-19

Employers say reclassifying coronavirus could be ‘ruinous’

Baby raccoon rescued from 10-foot deep drainage pipe on Vancouver Island

‘Its cries were loud, pitiful and heartbreaking,’ Saanich animal control officer says

Statistical flaws led to B.C. wolf cull which didn’t save endangered caribou as estimated

Study finds statistical flaws in an influential 2019 report supporting a wolf cull

Windows broken, racist graffiti left on Okanagan home

Family says nothing like this has happened since they moved to Summerland in 1980s

B.C. man who went by ‘Doctor Ray Gaglardi’ charged with sex assault of teenage boys

The man, 75, is accused of assaulting teenage boys he met through Coquitlam-area churches

B.C.’s potential deficit $12.5 billion as spending spikes, taxes drop

Finance Minister Carole James gives COVID-19 outlook

Canadians torn on scaling back COVID-19 benefits to save money: poll

Of those surveyed, 78 per cent said they were worried about the size of the deficit

‘Trauma equals addiction’: Why some seek solace in illicit drugs

Part 2: Many pushed into addiction by ‘toxic stress,’ says White Rock psychologist

Most Read