Referendum a mixed bag

The weekly editorial for the 100 Mile Free Press

In Mark Crawford’s column this week, he discusses the different options for the proportional representation referendum. He settles on Dual Member Proportional (DMP) as his choice because it’s “easiest to visualize locally,” “would not create two classes of MLAs” and “retain the same simple ballot,” as well as the details of the other two proposed systems remaining vague.

Politics aside, I wholeheartedly disagree with Crawford. From a local perspective, DMP offers the worst actual outcomes regardless of whether you’re in favour of PR or opposed. He assumes the Cariboo-Chilcotin riding, under DMP, would be amalgamated with Cariboo-North with two MLAs. If we look at the last election, the two ridings had a total of 26,948 votes combined. Of those 14,876 (55 per cent) went to the Liberals, 8231 (31 per cent) to the NDP, 3,094 (11 per cent) to the Greens and 747 (3 per cent) to the Conservatives. That election resulted in two Liberal MLAs, leaving 31 per cent (NDP) + 11 per cent (Greens) + 3 per cent (Conservatives), for a total of 45 per cent “not represented.”

READ ALSO: Perhaps the most important election

Under DMP, the Liberals would get the first MLA (31 per cent + one vote, to stay ahead of the NDP). The Liberals would then have 24 per cent of their voters “not represented” (55 – 31 per cent) with the NDP taking the second seat with their 31 per cent. In our combined ridings this would mean 24 per cent (the remaining Liberals) + 11 per cent (Greens) + 3 per cent (Conservatives), for a total of 38 per cent would still “not represented.” If you’re in favour of PR, not because of partisan politics, but because you believe we should have the most democratic system possible, that’s a pretty dissatisfying switch; it’s an improvement in terms of proportional representation, but you have to squint to be able to see it. At the same time, that relatively minor improvement in PR, comes at the cost of a district that’s twice as large, if you live in Quesnel, your nearest MLA could suddenly be in 100 Mile or vice versa. Both of the other systems would provide more proportionality without doubling the size of districts; for any rural voter, the latter should discard DMP as the worst choice regardless of your stance (it’s hard to believe a Quesnel based MLA would fight as hard for the South Cariboo as a South Cariboo based MLA). As a PR supporter, the former should only strengthen that resolve.

READ ALSO: If not Greyhound, it’s time to consider all options

The other two systems (MMP and RUP) should absolutely provide more proportionality than DMP but as Crawford points out, what they would look like in B.C. remains vague. Regardless of whether we end up back at FPTP or switch to PR, a discussion on the way we vote is absolutely worth having. It’s just too bad that the way the referendum is currently set up, it’s really hard to look at the options critically and in depth. This makes it an exceptionally tough task to get clarity for undecided voters. As much as one could commend the NDP and Green Party on following through on an election promise, the lacklustre execution is disappointing for PR proponents, looks sleezy from the perspective of FPTP supporters and should be downright scary for all rural voters with an option like DMP on the table that potentially offers few local gains in terms of PR but plenty to lose in terms of local representation.

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Nine new COVID-19 cases announced in Interior Health region

The total number of cases since the pandemic started is now at 531 for the region

Open burning prohibitions to be rescinded Sept. 30

The following activities will be allowed throughout the CFC’s jurisdiction:

Farmers’ market harvests successful season

Community steps up, supports vendors

School demolition brings up memories

Darlene ‘Dar’ Hastings couldn’t wait to attend the new 100 Mile High when it opened in 1960.

105 new COVID-19 cases, 1 death as health officials urge B.C. to remember safety protocols

There are currently 1268 active cases, with 3,337 people under public health monitoring

B.C. nurses report rise in depression, anxiety, exhaustion due to pandemic

A new UBC study looks into how the COVID-19 response has impacted frontline nurses

National child-care plan could help Canada rebound from COVID-induced economic crisis: prof

A $2 billion investment this year could help parents during second wave of pandemic

Search suspended for Indigenous elder last seen mushroom picking in northwest B.C.

Mushroom picker Thomas (Tommy) Dennis has been missing since Sept. 16

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

16 MLAs retiring from B.C. politics add up to $20M in pensions: Taxpayers Federation

Taxpayers pay $4 for every dollar MLAs contribute to their pensions

‘Bonnie’ and ‘Henry’ among latest litter of service dog puppies

B.C. Alberta Guide Dogs names two pups after provincial health officer

Zero new COVID-19 cases in Interior Health

Five cases remain linked to an outbreak at Calvary Chapel in Kelowna

Most Read