Lake access after court case

The weekly editorial for the 100 Mile Free Press

A recent court case against the Douglas Lake Cattle Company by the Nicola Valley Fish and Game Club saw the club prevail after a six-year protracted trial, with the ruling that the ranch cannot lawfully block access to the lake.

This was a true David and Goliath story with David coming out on top. While generally it was very much welcomed by much of the public as such, our web poll shows about 70 per cent in favour, David’s victory leaves a lot of questions.

B.C. Supreme Court Justice Joel Groves in the Reasons for Judgement notes “It would be nonsensical for a government to retain the rights to a lake if, by virtue of a single owner purchasing all the land surrounding a lake, that owner could prohibit public use or ownership of the lake. It only make[s] sense that government would have retained the ownership of bodies of water, lakes, with the intention of the public being allowed to access water they retained.”

However, in this particular case, that access is perhaps simpler than in many other cases across the province.

For instance in this case when it comes to maintaining the road in question “the annual cost was approximately $10,000, for a total, at the time of trial, of close to $300,000. These are expenditures paid by the government.”

Furthermore, the road leading up to the lakes was deemed a public road.

But the document doesn’t address how that access would happen where there is no public road.

“In their pleadings, the Club has alleged that the Province has a public duty to allow access to roads and lakes, and to allow fishing in lakes… I find that, in deciding the questions posed in this litigation, I need not directly decide whether the Province has such an obligation in regards to lakes and fisheries.”

Further noting that the Province does “not agree that they have an obligation to enforce a public right to lakes or fishing, or that there exists a public right to lakes or fishing.”

Groves concludes that ” In answer to the question raised by the club as to a common law right of access to lakes, again, I have determined that I need not consider this issue though I am strongly persuaded at an initial stage that there is substantial merit,” and that “in regards to the considerations of the Tresspass Act, I have determined that I need not make any determination.”

Yet finally, “In answer to the general determination of the Province’s obligations in regards to public access to road and lakes, though no legal public duty to maintain roads or to guarantee access to lakes have been proven, there is an overwhelming public duty on the Crown in maintaining ownership… to ensure that there is access to the public.”

Where that leaves the public and private property owners where no public road exists is pretty muddy.

However, personally, after some crazy wildfire seasons, I can think of at least one reason why the Province may want to own the lakes even if there’s no public access.

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

School demolition brings up memories

Darlene ‘Dar’ Hastings couldn’t wait to attend the new 100 Mile High when it opened in 1960.

Volunteering ‘best way to expand your bubble’

Val Severin serves the community as a way to give back

Old Timers Hockey league seeks players

The Old Timers Hockey Association is looking for players and increased community… Continue reading

Work begins on Clinton seniors’ living facility

Work has recently begun on a 20-bed seniors’ living facility in Clinton.

Unofficial holidays: Here’s what people are celebrating for the week of Sept. 27 to Oct. 3

World Farm Animals Day, Drink Beer Day and Virus Appreciation Day are all coming up this week

QUIZ: Do you know what’s on TV?

Fall is normally the time when new television shows are released

Canadian ski resorts wrestle with pandemic-vs.-profit dilemma as COVID-19 persists

Few are actually restricting the total number of skiers they allow on the hill

Victoria-area RCMP locate high-risk sex offender thanks to help of taxi cab driver

Scott Jones wanted on a Canada-wide warrant, ‘a risk to women and girls,’ police say

A (virtual) walk around the world by 88-year-old B.C. man

George Doi says it’s simple: ‘I like walking’

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

End of CERB means uncertainty for some, new system for others

As of a week ago, the CERB had paid out $79.3 billion to 8.8 million people

Horgan, Wilkinson trade barbs over MSP premiums, health care at campaign stops

Horgan called a snap election for Oct. 24 earlier this week

Most Read