Drastic drop in South Cariboo cattle

Fewer farms, cattle and operators in the South Cariboo

“It’s a shame when a 65-year-old rancher has to wake up at three o’clock in the morning and have that overwhelming feeling of loss. It’s a sad day. I can get emotional about it,” says Pete Bonter. “I have nobody to succeed me.”

Bonter is a third-generation rancher whose six children have all decided to pursue other, more lucrative career choices than agriculture.

“Three generations of effort comes to a halt when I close my front gate and that’s sad because you have to ask yourself… what is the inevitable outcome of three generations of life. I mean three generations worked hard on this place of mine and, now, what was it for?”

Census data from Statistics Canada indicates that Bonter, who’s also the president of the South Cariboo Cattlemen’s Association, may be far from the only person struggling with succession. The data shows the number of farms (which includes cattle ranches), the number of cattle and the number of farm operators have all sharply declined in the South Cariboo from 2011 to 2016. Nationally, similar decreases took place albeit much less severe.

In the South Cariboo (Cariboo area G, Lac la Hache to 93 Mile excl. 100 Mile House, Cariboo area H, just north of 100 Mile House to Mahood Lake, and Cariboo area L, Horse Lake, Interlakes and Deka Lake), total farms decreased from 267 to 191; a 28 per cent drop (compared to a six per cent decrease nationally and 11 per cent in B.C.).

Additionally, while in Canada and B.C. the number of farms 3520 acres and over increased, in the South Cariboo, the number of farms 3520 acres and over decreased from 12 to 11.

Consequently, the South Cariboo also saw the number of operators drop by 25 per cent from 395 to 295.

This is a trend that’s been going on for decades, according to Wayne Caldwell, a professor at the University of Guelph, who focusses on the future of rural communities in the areas of planning, community development, agricultural land preservation and rural land use.

“Really what we’re observing is a trend that’s continued pretty much unabated since the end of the Second World War in many ways, where we find that increasing capitalization on many farms leading to larger farms, fewer farm operators and yet if we look at things from a production perspective the total value of production [and] the total volume of production tends to be fairly consistently increasing over that time period,” says Caldwell. This general push where “if you’re a little bit larger, you tend to be a little bit more viable from certain points of view and it really is a challenge for some communities in farm numbers which sometimes means there’s a decline in employment on the farm as well.”

He adds that ultimately it really comes down to economic viability.

“The key thing that we all want, I think, is we want people to be making good livings in farms and on agriculture. And I think there’s a sweet spot there, if I can put it that way, where you need to be large enough to be able to cope and yet in many small communities you want the scale to be set so that there’s a reasonable proliferation of farms as well.”

In the South Cariboo, however, it may be a slightly different story as not only did the number of farms over 3520 acres decrease, unlike Canada and B.C., the South Cariboo also saw a steep drop in the total number of cattle and calves from 13,731 to 9,541; a 31 per cent drop.

Bonter says that large ranches prefer to operate in areas other than the South Cariboo.

“Historically, we have smaller ranches in the South Cariboo anyhow but the demographics of it is that we’re all getting older and this is a particularly hard area to ranch in,” says Bonter. “The shift right now is from smaller to larger holdings. We see that provincially, and I think in my estimation of it, the issue that we’re seeing in the South Cariboo [is that] very few large ranches want to be involved with the cost of producing beef in the South Cariboo. I mean, we’re high elevation. We are limited in the types of crops that we can grow. Basically, the South Cariboo is a grass growing part of our province and so when you see the shift from small to large, the large are operating in areas other than the South Cariboo. So there are some extenuating circumstances to all of that but primarily a lot of our producers are just retiring.”

The average operator age in 2016 was 59.5 in area G, 57.4 in area H and 59.8 area L, nearly five years higher than the national average which stands at 55.

Bonter says that the input costs are so high that it eats up too much of the income for ranchers.

“That doesn’t leave enough for young people to be attracted to the industry,” says Bonter. “We have six kids and there are none of them that are interested in resuming where I leave off because of the dollar value.”

As ranchers start to retire, there are really only a few possible scenarios, says Caldwell.

“As someone gets to 60, 65, 70 or 75 even, if there’s not someone to take the farm over, it either then is going to get swallowed up by a large operation… you got to have new people to coming in or take over the farms or the farms, … depending again on the quality of soil and the quality of the farming environment, run the risk of going out of production.”

The larger Cariboo area fared better in all categories with total farms decreasing by 16 per cent, farms over 3520 acres increasing from 66 to 77 and total cattle and calves increasing by 2 per cent with operators decreasing by 13 per cent. The average operator age in the wider Cariboo area was 57.1.

Ultimately, Bonter says he’s worried about the future of ranching in the South Cariboo and about Canadian food production.

“It’s not a pretty picture and ultimately, we have to have a solution. What is that solution and what will it look like? I don’t know.”

He adds that it’s not easy for ranchers to give up what they and their families have often worked on for generations.

“When you are the third generation, you are tied emotionally. I mean my grandfather worked on this piece of ground. My uncles worked on this piece of ground. I’ve worked on it along with my whole family and it’s not something that you just readily give up. So I am tied emotionally to this ground and I don’t plan on leaving it.”

Bonter hopes that he can find someone to take over his ranch but as the data shows, at least in the South Cariboo, he would be one of the lucky ones.

“I would love nothing better than to devote the rest of my days to having one of my children make it in ranching… but that opportunity is not going to be afforded to me. I want to be part of some young person making it on my place and that will be my dying goal” he says. “I guess unless I’m starving to death my dying goal will be to see some young person have an opportunity on my place.”



Canada: total farms decreased from 205,730 to 193,492 (16,200 with a succession plan)

Canada: farms 3520 acres and over increased from 8,419 to 9,089

BC: total farms decreased from 19,759 to 17,528 (1,175 with a succession plan)

BC: farms 3520 acres and over increased from 314 to 340

Cariboo: total farms decreased from 1,681 to 1,411 (64 with a succession plan) 16 per cent drop

Cariboo: farms 3520 acres and over increased from 66 to 77

Cariboo G: total farms decreased from 73 to 58 (3 with a succession plan)

Cariboo G: farms 3520 acres and over decreased from 6 to 4

Cariboo H: total farms decreased from 77 to 48 (0 with a succession plan)

Cariboo H: farms 3520 acres and over increased from 2 to 3

Cariboo L: total farms decreased from 117 to 85 (4 with a succession plan)

Cariboo L: farms 3520 acres and stayed at 4 to 4

South Cariboo 28 per cent drop



Canada: total cattle and calves decreased from 12,789,965 to 12,530,730

BC: total cattle and calves increased from 620,638 to 659,441

Cariboo: total cattle and calves increased from 113,223 to 115,657

Cariboo G: total cattle and calves decreased from 7,130 to 3,799

Cariboo H: total cattle and calves decreased from 2,398 to 2,194

Cariboo L: total cattle and calves decreased from 4,203 to 3,548

South Cariboo 31 per cent drop



Canada: total operators decreased from 293,925 to 271,935

Canada: males from 213,265 to 193,965

Canada: females from 80,665 to 77,970

BC: total operators decreased from 29,925 to 26,430

BC: males from 19,010 to 16,515

BC: females from 10,915 to 9,925

Cariboo: total operators decreased from 2,530 to 2,200

Cariboo: males from 1,555 to 1,305

Cariboo: females from 975 to 895

Cariboo G: total operators decreased from 110 to 85

Cariboo G: males from 65 to 50

Cariboo G: females from 45 to 30

Cariboo H: total operators decreased from 115 to 75

Cariboo H: males from 60 to 45

Cariboo H: females from 55 to 35

Cariboo L: total operators decreased from 170 to 135

Cariboo L: males from 110 to 75

Cariboo L: females from 55 to 55

South Cariboo 25 per cent drop (395 to 295)



Canada: average operator age from 54 to 55

BC: average operator age from 55.7 to 56.3

Cariboo: average operator age from 56.7 to 57.1

Cariboo G: average operator age from 56.8 to 59.5

Cariboo H: average operator age from 58.9 to 57.4

Cariboo L: average operator age from 58.9 to 59.8



Canada: more than 40 hours per week from 117,985 to 102,070

BC: more than 40 hours per week from 7,695 to 6,450

Cariboo: more than 40 hours per week from 725 to 595

Cariboo G: more than 40 hours per week from 30 to 15

Cariboo H: more than 40 hours per week from 25 to 15

Cariboo L: more than 40 hours per week from 40 to 35

South Cariboo 32 per cent drop


BC: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting 1.9 to 1.74 per cent of GDP

BC Agriculture: 3.779.9 to 4,270.1 x 1000,000

BC Animal production: 499.2 to 5.28.7 x 1000,000

Just Posted

Bus company eyeing passenger and cargo service departing from Williams Lake, stopping in Quesnel

Merritt Bus Shuttle Services Ltd. would have a driver based in Williams Lake for the route to Prince George

100 Mile House starts getting into the Christmas spirit with Farmer’s Market

Santa Clause will make an appearance during the Christmas Market

100 Mile Wranglers get tripped up by Nelson and Kelowna

New goalie added, preparing for upcoming games

South Cariboo bags three medals in figure skating competition in Revelstoke

Two girls brought home gold, while the third brought home silver

People flocking to Vancouver Island city to see hundreds of sea lions

Each year the combination of Steller and California sea lions take over Cowichan Bay

Baloney Meter: Will tougher penalties for gang members make Canada safer?

Since 2013, gang-related homicides in Canada’s largest cities have almost doubled

Early data suggests no spike in pot-impaired driving after legalization: police

Some departments said it’s too early to provide data, others said initial numbers suggest stoned driving isn’t on the rise

Protesters confront Environment Minister in B.C.

Protesters wanting more for killer whales confront Catherine McKenna

Humans reshaping evolutionary history of species around the globe: paper

University of British Columbia researcher had the paper published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society

Toronto ‘carding’ activist Desmond Cole stopped by police in Vancouver

Cole says his experience reveals what daily life is like for black and Indigenous residents

Commercial trucks banned from left lane of Coquihalla

B.C.’s Ministry of Transportation has introduced a new program that hopes to prevent accidents and closures on the Coquihalla Highway.

B.C. on track to record same number of overdose deaths as last year

128 people died of overdoses in September, bringing the total to more than 1,100 so far in 2018

B.C. firefighters rescue horse stuck in mud

‘It happens more often than you’d think,’ says deputy chief

Most Read